top of page

Carnival Group - P&O - Costa - Princess - Seabourn - Holland America

Carnival Corporation - Brands



Part two - Again please be mindful that these are my own personal recommendations based on my experience onboard and the feedback from clients we have booked. I have included photos that are representative of cabin decor, sizes and signature interior spaces.

I make no claim to be the font of all knowledge.

If you disagree, I really am keen to know how and why your experience might be different.

We do have reports from a few people that have had exceptional experiences on some of the lines below that I don't recommend. What is written below doe not imply that I am skeptical of what they have reported back. I absolutely believe them.

The issue is one of consistency and I simply can't in good conscience recommend a particular cruise if I am aware of reports of poor service or product.

Others will simply take your money. That is not how we roll.


The Carnival Corporation Brands

 

Costa Cruises

3 star 12 ships - 2000 to 4000 pax Founded in 1854. Based in Genoa, Italy, the cruise line primarily caters to the Italian cruise market You might remember the Costa Concordia Dare I say it Euro-trash. FAB: Avoid.

 

P&O Cruises Australia


3/4 Star 3 ships 2000-2600 Pax Average age 20+ years Lots of history here being a direct descendant of the Peninsular & Oriental Steam Navigation Company which is one of the oldest cruise lines in the world. The backbone of migration between the UK and Australia. Prior to the advent of cheap international flights in the 70s, if Australians went to Europe, more times than not, it was on one of their ocean liners. Sadly the glamour of that bygone era is well ... gone. The bare bones that remain here in the current Australian operation here today bear little resemblance to what was such a strong pedigree as they are now very much an entry-level product firmly at the bottom of the market. Which confusingly is very different to the standard of the product offered by P&O UK, with newer and better-designed ships.

The fleet is made up of old ships, with cosmetic makeovers that show their age with small cabins and dated decor in the areas that haven't been tarted up. Reports of visible rust and cold and at times uneatable food. They are definitely improving but they are still very much hit-and-miss, which to my mind is too much of a risk for your hard-earned holiday dollars Cheap wine is great, if it's undrinkable you have wasted your money and stuffed up a lovely dinner. P&O offers loads of short sample cruises of 2 or 3 nights for a few hundred dollars. Avoid these at whatever the cost unless you like the Kuta beach crowd or a non stop bucks party.

The relentless push for extra revenue onboard is not just tiresome, it can be crippling financially if you had only budgeted for a few hundred dollars for your 'cheap' cruise.

As with airlines, the budget option can actually work out to be more expensive than a premium brand by the time you pay for seat allocation, meals, a movie, and a bag down below. The same rules apply to cruise lines.

FAB: Avoid until they are not hit and miss which may not be until they get better ships


 

P&O Cruises UK


4/5 star 6 ships 2000, 3500, 5000 pax Good mid-range product favored by lots of Brits who tend to like to travel en-mass ... think Majorca on Sea. With that in mind, their product is built to keep this demographic coming back for more. Large ships that do lots of itineraries ex the UK


FAB: Better options on lines that are not based in the UK but still visit there

 

Carnival Cruise Line


3 Star 2000, 4000 up to 5000 pax on the new ships. Again entry level. The biggest cruise line in the world with 19 ships. Many 20+ years old.

You get what you pay for and you won't pay much - think a basic 3 star hotel.

Like P&O Aust they offer lots of short sampler cruises. Don't, just don't.

Big kid and family focus which is great if you have kids. If not, not so much.

Loads of extra charges for everything except meals.


FAB: Better quality options available. If you can only afford Carnival, skip a year save your money and spend a few hundred dollars more on Royal Caribbean


 

Princess Cruises



4/5 star 15 ships. 2600 to 3600 One name. One company. But like with P&O their product locally is very different to abroad. Which again I think is nuts from a marketing perspective.

Princess and Carnival apparently view Australia as a retirement home for the older ships which frustrates me no end. We deserve ships as good as those overseas but instead many brands give us the old girls and expect us to pay a premium to sail on them.

A case in point, Dawn Princess looked for all the world like an RSL when she was transferred to Australia in 2007. Consequently, the RSL crowd loved her. She was showing her age back in 2007 but Carnival at a corporate level decided instead of pensioning her off, to simply throw a bit of paint over her and transfer her to P&O.

This is the reason why I'm no big fan of the local versions of Carnival, Princess or P&O.

Princess overseas however is a different bird with more modern ships and has broader appeal. Debbie in our office loved her cruise around the Med on Princess. But let it be said she hasn't sailed on Princess in Australia.

FAB: Recommended for retirees

 

Holland America Line


4/5 star - 9 ships, 1400, 2000, 2700 pax HAL was founded in Rotterdam, Netherlands in 1873 and was instrumental in the mass migration of people from Europe to the USA. Hence the name.

HALs days of glory on the transatlantic route faded with the rise of aviation in the 70s Like Princess, they have a product that is designed for older travelers without big flashy kids clubs and they tend to do longer 10/14+ day voyages.

A solid product with great food and fantastic service but the ships are nothing to get excited about.

They have also chosen to base their older ship here ... Can you see a trend here?

FAB: Recommended for retirees

 

Cunard Line


4/5 star - 3 ships, older fleet 2 @ 2000 pax, 1 @ 2600 pax

In 1839, Samuel Cunard was awarded the first British transatlantic steamship mail contract, and the next year formed the British and North American Royal Mail Steam-Packet Company. It was renamed Cunard in 1879.

Cunard has a pedigree built on the back of the white star line and the legendary transatlantic route. Back in the day, they had a fleet of true ocean liners which were the most luxurious and glamorous ships afloat favored by royalty and high society. No one came close. When the new-age cruise ships began to emerge Cunard feared being left behind and decided to follow the crowd and build big ships that had little in common with the exclusive first-class product was famous for.

Sadly little remains of the glamour of the last century with the exception of traditional main dining rooms like the Queens Grill and white-gloved high tea every afternoon. It is my personal view it was a bad move that saw Cunard lose their way and give up the prestigious place at the very top of the industry. They are now very much a mid-market brand these days.

That being said I have very well-traveled clients who cruise on all the high-end lines and they report about a recent voyage on Cunard that they loved the whole experience. Let's hope they are having a resurgence but without new smaller ships, they will not be able to match or catch the ultra-luxurious 6-star brands that lead the pack.


FAB: Recommended for retirees and more mature pax

 

Seabourn Cruise Line



6 star - 6 ships Inclusive of tips/drinks/mini bar 1 @ 264, 3 @ 450, 2 @ 600 pax

All suite - all inclusive of drinks/tips/mini bar


Carnival's 6-star brand. Whereas on other lines extras such as tips, drinks, and mini bar can see onboard expenses skyrocket to $1000 or more, Seabourn includes all of these in their fares. So although on face value they may seem more expensive, when you do the math, often they can be the same total spend, or in some cases even cheaper than mid-range options for a far superior experience.

To use another airline analogy - if a budget brand like Costa is like the middle seat, in the back row on RyanAir, then Seabourn is like first class 24/7. I've been privileged to have sailed on most cruise lines. If cost is no object, I'd recommend Seabourn over all others, and is my favorite line in the world. Luxuriously appointed with understated decor reminiscent of a private super yacht.



Seabourn might lack other perks such as butlers on Silversea or the inclusions of excursions offered by Regent, but the advantage to me is that Seabourn has a more relaxed dress code.


Relaxed yet stylish is their onboard vibe and you won't feel out of place with a smart collared shirt, slacks, and no jacket.

Others might prefer to dress up every night. But for most Australians Seabourn is a more relaxed option.

New to the Expedition space, their 264 Pax Venture - think a Vogue Safari - is stunning yet understated and even features two submarines.

FAB: Highly recommended

 

Read the next post in this series: Cruiselines: NCL Corp - Regent - Oceania



Step by step guide to find your perfect cruise ... Jump ahead to:

FAB Last Minute and Interline Cruises





Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Why choose nib?
    nib has 24-hour support with call centre staff based in Australia and international phone numbers you can access around the world. Many online insurance providers have no call centres or anyone you can speak to before your policy commences or during the claim process. Other providers may require you to purchase cover more than 21 days prior to departure otherwise any Covid event will not be covered. Other providers have specific cruise coverage, but if you read the fine print, they may not cover Covid once you board a cruise ship or any time after that. Credit card insurance may not provide the cover you expect, ask us for our Credit Card Myths Flyer and a checklist you can use to check your level of protection. We offer policies with no age limits and single trips in excess of 60 days. Our multi-trip annual policies are now offered by very few providers. Often times our annual multi-trip policy will work out cheaper than a single-trip policy.
  • I work for an Australian airline as a pilot or cabin crew, am I covered while on an overnight?
    When you are operating a pattern and staying in a company provided hotel you are considered to be at work. While carrying out your duties as an employee, you should be covered by your employer’s worker’s compensation insurance. That is if you become unwell or injured, while on an aircraft, in company provided transport, within the crew hotel and what is considered reasonable proximity to the crew hotel. There are limitations, and crew that choose to leave the city where they are staying might not be covered by worker’s compensation. The problem has been that for crew who choose to go "Off-Station", (for example a trip from LA to Las Vegas), up until now there have been no options available to provide insurance protection in the event of an accident, lost luggage, or if medical assistance is required. As we all know, in the USA especially, public liability and medical costs can be crippling. The good news is nib’s Annual Multi Trip Plan can offer protection for cabin crew and pilots. Even snow sports can be covered for an additional premium. The details of exactly what situations are and are not covered are laid out in the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS). Continue reading below for a quick summary of key features of this cover but it is critical that you read and understand the PDS in full. What is covered? When you go "Off-Station", you are not considered to be at work, and provided you abide by all the terms and conditions of the policy, the cover includes: Rental vehicle insurance excess Overseas medical expenses (including for COVID-19) Repatriation Cover for certain COVID-19 related events Accidental loss, theft or damage to luggage By paying an additional premium other options can be added to a policy such as: Snow sports cover option Specified items option for high value items over $1000 such as: Personal Electronics Sports and other leisure equipment Other luggage Travel within Australia too This same protection is also applicable to Domestic Crew patterns, or for travel undertaken on days off, with the proviso that the trip: starts and ends at your home in Australia is more than 200 kms from your home in Australia. includes travel by either pre-paid scheduled public transport or hire car, or include at least one night of pre-booked publicly available accommodation "Off-Station" Insurance cover for cabin crew and pilots Save up to 30% Annual cover from $466 (Single policy - Age 59) For the same low price you also get: unlimited annual leave + leisure trips that are less than 45 days international and domestic for trips more than 200kms from home children can be added for free Pay a higher premium to add: your spouse/partner if single, a fellow single traveller cover for snow sports or high-value items like jewelry and laptops In a nutshell nib’s Annual Multi Trip Plan provides cover when you are not at work. When you go "Off-Station' you are considered not to be at work. This is premium coverage that will cover you for holidays as well. Always refer to PDS for coverage details >
  • What about Corona virus coverage?
    All Single Comprehensive and Annual Multi-Trip policies include coverage for Covid events. Important: Essential policies have no Covid protection. ​ The two elements to Covid cover which confuse many people are cancellation cost and medical/repatriation coverage. Single Comprehensive and Annual Multiple provide BOTH cancellation and medical
  • What cancellation costs due to Covid are covered?
    Both the Comprehensive/Annual Multi policies provide coverage for cancellation fees due to 8 covid specified reasons up to $2500 per person. If your policy is for one adult, that is $2500. If for two, that becomes $5000. You can add children to any policy but this limit of $2500 per adult will not increase. Insurance Cover is not available for loss arising from: government intervention including travel bans, border closures or broadly imposed quarantine requirements; events for which the Government has issued a 'Do Not Travel' warning for your destination, or failure to follow advice from official bodies, including vaccination advice where applicable. Refer to the Product Disclosure Statement for detailed information.
  • What about medical costs and/or repatriation due to Covid?
    Comprehensive/Multi policies will both cover medical expenses and repatriation costs due to covid. These are different and are not restricted to the $2500 per adult for cancellation fees, up to set limits and relevant clauses of each policy. Refer PDS for further info.
  • Are there maximum age limits?
    There are no age limits, however, the cost of insurance increases with the risk. Expect policies for those over 70 to be expensive, as up until now it was almost impossible to secure insurance over this age.
  • Are children covered?
    Children are covered at no additional charge. ​ If they fall within the below definition, they can be added to policies at no additional charge. ​Your children, stepchildren, grandchildren, foster children, and children for whom you are the legal guardian, who are travelling with you on the same itinerary for the entire duration of your trip and at the time the Certificate of Insurance is issued are: under 25 years of age, and working less than 30 hours per week ​How to add Children: Start your quote for two adults and you will be asked to add dependants at a later time.
  • Can singles who are not in a relationship or live in the same household purchase a joint Multi-Trip policy?
    Yes, and there is no requirement to travel together.
  • What if I have pre-existing medical conditions?
    Up to 40 conditions are automatically covered. For many other conditions, you can complete screening online and have your quote adjusted accordingly. Others may need you to contact the nib Pre-Existing Health Team, for clarification and pricing. For all technical questions about what is covered and preexisting medical Call nib on 1300 410 272 ​(Monday to Friday. 9 AM to 6 PM)
  • What is not covered?
    To ensure you don't get caught out, you must read the Product Disclosure Statement and the terms and conditions in full, which are an essential part of your quote/policy. For all technical questions about what is covered and preexisting medical Call nib on 1300 410 272 ​ (Monday to Friday. 9 AM to 6 PM)
  • Am I covered in all countries and jurisdictions?
    No. You will not be covered if you travel to, or remain in, a country on the Do Not Travel List. Check www.smartraveller.gov.au/ prior to making payment, before departure and during the course of your international travel.
  • How do I make payment?
    If you are happy with the quote, simply make a payment on the nib website with a credit card.
  • Are there annual policies or just single trip policies?
    nib offers both single trip and annual policies. Covid protection is included in both Comprehensive Single Trip and Annual Multi-Trip Policies. Important: Essentials Single Trip policies have no covid protection
  • Is this offer open to people outside Australia?
    No. This offer is only for Australian residents.
  • Further questions?
    You must first generate a quote via the attached link then call 1300 410 272 (Monday to Friday. 9 AM to 6 PM) advise them of your Quote Number.. With nib, unlike many other providers, you will speak to a real person here in Australia.
  • Interline rules - Ts and Cs #
    INTERLINE CONDITIONS: In addition to all standard conditions of carriage of the operator you and all members of your travelling party must abide by the following: 1/ You must not disclose to any other guest on your cruise the nature of the discounts you have received. 2/ Any such breach can see the cruise operator, at their discretion, convert your fare to full commercial rates and you will be liable for the difference. 3/ As with staff travel on the airline of your employment, your behaviour must always be above reproach. Unruly and unacceptable levels of intoxication and abuse of staff are strictly forbidden and the operator has the right to offload you at any time. 4/ The operator can at any time revoke your ability to purchase future interline discounts. 5/ Interline rates are a privilege, not a right. You are entitled to them solely through the relevant interline agreement, which is a benefit directly related to your employment. Any unacceptable behaviour will be reported back to your employer which could result in the loss of airline staff benefits, and/or further disciplinary action. 6/ Eligible staff members need to realise that these rules apply to any beneficiary who books interline rates under their name. These rules must be clearly communicated to all passengers travelling under their benefit entitlement. INTERLINE RATES: You must provide us proof of employment in aviation for an Interline Rate. Unless otherwise advised, Interline bookings are non-refundable. Prices may change before departure. A price drop does not entitle you to any refund of your fare, (either deposits or full payments). We will always endeavour to get a price adjustment but understand that this is unlikely. FAB does not guarantee or warrant cruise itineraries. Itinerary changes are at the discretion of the cruise lines. Changes to itineraries are governed by the T&Cs of the cruise lines. Where we act as an agent, our quotes and itineraries will include a statement that advises you: • We act as an Agent; and • That our Terms and Conditions are in addition to the Terms and Conditions of each Travel supplier listed on the quote/itinerary; and • That it is the Terms and Conditions of the Travel supplier that determine the terms of • cancellation and refunds, if any INSURANCE: As most interline fares are 100% non-refundable, we urge you to consider the advice of the Australian Government that recommends everyone should purchase Travel Insurance. As a 6 Star 4 Less customer, you can get up to 30% off nib Travel Insurance. We have policies with no age limits that cover both cruises and covid related events (many do not). Our Annual multi-trip options may be cheaper than a single-trip policy. Read our guide on how insurance policies are priced when to buy, and how to save money: www.fabinterlinecruises.com/insurance If you have not already taken out Travel Insurance with us, please read the following carefully: If you become ill with Coronavirus If you are cruising and become ill with Coronavirus If you lose your luggage If you become ill or have an accident If you suffer the pain of a toothache or damage your teeth through an accident If you lose your tickets, travellers cheques, passport etc. If your transport is delayed If a relative at home becomes sick or dies If any of these things happen to you and you have no Travel Insurance, it will probably ruin what should have been a wonderful experience. Fab Interline Cruises, ABN 19610361025 is a distributor of NIB Travel Services (Australia) Pty Ltd (nib), ABN 81 115 932 173, AFSL 308461 and receives a commission for nib products purchased through Fab Interline Cruises. Fab Interline Cruises acts as an agent for NIB and not as your agent. FAB Interline Cruises cannot give advice about nib products, and any factual information provided is not intended to imply a recommendation or opinion about nib products. Before you buy, please read the Product Disclosure Statement, Financial Services Guide and Target Market Determination (TMD) available from us. If you have a complaint about a nib product, see the Product Disclosure Statement for the complaints process. This insurance is underwritten by Pacific International Insurance Pty Ltd, ABN 83 169 311 193. Please contact me to arrange your Insurance cover. DEPOSITS AND FINAL PAYMENTS: You have the sole responsibility to ensure all payments are made by the stated deadlines. Reservations will be automatically cancelled and money paid will be lost if deadlines are missed. PASSPORTS: It is your responsibility to ensure your passport and travel documents are valid and in good order. Most countries and cruise lines require a minimum of 6 months of validity and some require that you have a completely blank page in your passport. VISAS: You must understand the VISA requirements for each port are. You are responsible to ensure that you obtain all required VISAS prior to departure. Failure to do so may see you denied boarding at the port of departure. We can not be held responsible for any problems or delays with the issuing of passports or the correct validity of Visas. VISIT https://smartraveller.gov.au/Pages/default.aspx
  • Eligibility + Verification
    All interline rates are fares are strictly controlled - closed rates. To obtain a quote and to book we must first verify that you are eligible. Our contracts with the cruise lines require us verify everyone who requests access to interline fares, at time of booking and potentially onboarding on request. There are some grey areas. Technically the rules refer to current and 'retired' staff. Sometimes benefits can be extended to people who have worked for an airline for some time and have left prior to retirement age. All of our contracts are different and if in doubt it is critical that ask us before making any deposit payment. As a general rule if you still have access to airline staff discounts you will automatically be accepted by the cruise lines. Your parents can travel without you, and in almost all cases you can book a second cabin at interline rates even for people that don't work for an airline, The only requirement is that you travel on the same cruise. Your parents may also be able to book two cabins as well. If you want to book. ore than two cabins, ask us, as some lines will permit us to book several with just one ID. If your service was some time ago, the cruise lines with automatically ask for a statement of service. This must detail start and end of years of service. A training certificate or similar will automatically be rejected. If you were at Ansett at the time of the collapse refer to our separate section especially for you.
bottom of page